About Us

The Local Agents Behind Your Coverage in Tifton

We're an independent insurance agency in Tifton, GA, formed when two longtime local agencies joined forces, so you keep the neighbors you've always known while gaining access to more carriers than either could offer alone.

Black shield icon with a white checkmark in a circle

What Kind of Agency We Are

Independent and Trusted Choice

We're an independent agency, which means we work for the people we serve rather than a single insurance company. Our Trusted Choice designation reflects that commitment.

Two Tifton Agencies, One Local Team

We were formed when two established Tifton agencies came together, bringing decades of combined history under one roof on Second Street.

Rooted in This Community

Our agents live and work in Tifton, anchored by more than 40 years of local insurance experience and deep ties across Tift County.

Smiling woman in a red blouse standing outdoors in front of a brick wall and greenery

Gina Nelson

Agent

Gina is a native of Garden City, just outside of Savannah. She is a graduate of Mercer University with a Bachelor of Arts degree in Psychology and Master of Business Administration with a concentration in Management. After completing her Bachelor’s degree, Gina began working at GEICO in the Management Training program. She worked as a claim adjuster before being promoted to claim supervisor, HR manager, and claim manager in the Internal Auto Damage department.


Gina took time off to stay at home with her children before returning to the insurance industry with Kincaid Insurance Agency in 2016. She enjoys the relationships she has established with her clients and takes pride in being a trusted advocate for their personal and business insurance needs. Gina is married to Paul, an educator in the Tift County School System. They have three children, Max, Martha Jane, and Maggie.

Portrait of a woman wearing glasses, a blue top, and a silver cross necklace outdoors.

Stephanie Clark

Agent

With over a decade of experience in the insurance industry since 2012, Stephanie is dedicated to providing clients with knowledgeable, dependable, and personalized service. She specializes in helping individuals, families, and businesses navigate their insurance needs with confidence by offering tailored coverage solutions and clear communication every step of the way. Known for her professionalism, attention to detail, and commitment to building lasting relationships, Stephanie takes pride in making the insurance process simple, approachable, and focused on protecting what matters most to her clients. Outside of her career, she is a proud wife, mother of three, and “Nonnie” to three beautiful grandchildren, values that continue to inspire her passion for helping protect the people and things families cherish most.

Smiling woman in a navy blazer with curly hair, standing outdoors against greenery.

Whitney Goff

Agent

With over 13 years of experience, I am a licensed Property and Casualty Agent who deeply cares about protecting what matters most to you. My journey began right in my hometown of Adel, Georgia, during a high school senior work-study program. Over the years, my favorite part of this job has remained the same: connecting with people. My clients quickly become just like family, and I strive to deliver that warm, trusted hometown service to everyone who walks through our doors.



When I am not helping clients, my time belongs to my wonderful husband of 16 years and our sweet boy. They are my entire world and my daily inspiration. I bring that same love, dedication, and protective care from my home straight into my work every single day.

Smiling person with curly hair in a gray coat standing outdoors near a building

Bethany Wynn

Agent

With 10 years of experience in the insurance industry, Bethany is dedicated to helping customers find the coverage that best meets their needs while providing exceptional service every step of the way. Her favorite part of being a member of the SBY&K family is the lasting relationships she has built with customers over the years.



A proud Turner County native, Bethany and her husband enjoy being part of the community they call home. Her husband is a Marine Corps veteran who served nearly 10 years in the military and later dedicated several years to serving the community as a paramedic. When they’re not at work, they love camping, taking road trips, and making memories with their three beloved fur babies.

Smiling woman in a red sweater with long dark hair, standing outdoors near greenery.

Crystal Blanchett 

Agent

Crystal Hunter Blanchett has been serving clients in the insurance industry since 2012 and is proud to be part of the Sumner, Beaumont, York and Kincaid Insurance Group team. She specializes in commercial insurance and has experience across all lines of commercial coverage, helping business owners find the right protection for their unique needs with knowledgeable, personalized service.


A graduate of Abraham Baldwin Agricultural College and Valdosta State University, Crystal combines her education with years of industry experience to provide knowledgeable, personalized guidance to her clients.



Originally from Ocilla, Georgia, Crystal is the proud wife and mother of two daughters. She enjoys building lasting relationships with her clients and would love the opportunity to help protect your business with the right insurance solutions.

Stop By or Reach Out Whenever You're Ready

You're always welcome at our Second Street office, or you can reach us by phone or through our contact form whenever it's convenient. However you get in touch, a local agent who knows Tifton will be the one to help you.